International Journal of Medical and All Body Health Research
Integrating Emergency Preparedness Frameworks into Community-Based Reproductive Health Programming in African Countries
Charlotte Ogechukwu Nwagwu1, Mercy Osato Omoifo-Irefo2, Peter Omololu Subair3
- 1
- 2
- 3
This is an author-deposited copy. The version of record was originally published elsewhere: Originally published in International Journal of Medical and All Body Health Research, Volume 5, Issue 2, 2024. DOI 10.54660/IJMBHR.2024.5.4.278-285 . Original source: https://www.allmedicaljournal.com/archives/year-2024.vol-5.issue-2.
Abstract
Background: Reproductive health services are among the first services to become unstable during epidemics, armed conflict, flooding, drought, displacement, and broader health-system shocks. In African settings, community-based reproductive health programming often depends on community health workers, outreach teams, local referral networks, and decentralized commodity delivery, but emergency preparedness frameworks have historically been designed more visibly around national surveillance, tertiary facilities, and general health security structures than around continuity of local reproductive health access. Objective: This study assessed the extent to which emergency preparedness was integrated into reproductive health continuity arrangements in African countries and examined which operational components were most and least frequently documented in official continuity planning during the COVID-19 period. The analysis also tested whether countries documenting more preparedness actions preserved a broader reproductive health continuity package. Methods: A secondary, multi-country comparative analysis was conducted using the World Health Organization Regional Office for Africa rapid assessment on continuity of essential sexual and reproductive health services. Twenty-four countries with complete continuity-package data were included. Three continuity indicators were coded from country tables, namely family planning, comprehensive abortion care, and post-abortion care. Eleven preparedness-action indicators were coded from the same source, covering triage, infection prevention and control, self-care, multi-month dispensing, supply-chain maintenance, community-based distribution and outreach, guideline revision, coordination, supportive supervision, data monitoring, and explicit facility-level essential-service designation. A continuity score, action index, and composite integration score were calculated. Descriptive statistics, regional comparison, Spearman correlation, and Poisson regression were used. Results: Family planning appeared in 95.8 percent of continuity packages, post-abortion care in 91.7 percent, and comprehensive abortion care in 50.0 percent. The mean continuity score was 2.38 of 3 and the mean preparedness-action score was 2.13 of 11. Guideline revision was the most common action at 41.7 percent, followed by infection-prevention strengthening at 29.2 percent and supply-chain management, coordination, and data monitoring at 25.0 percent each. Community-based distribution and outreach were documented in only 12.5 percent of countries, and multi-month dispensing in 8.3 percent. Uganda had the highest composite integration score, followed by Ghana. South Sudan had the lowest. The action index was positively associated with the continuity score, but the coefficient was imprecise in adjusted models. Conclusion: African countries more commonly protected the policy inclusion of reproductive health services than the decentralized operational mechanisms needed to keep community-based access functioning in crisis conditions. Preparedness integration was therefore partial rather than fully institutionalized. The findings support a shift from emergency response that begins once disruption starts to routine reproductive health programming that is designed from the outset for continuity, decentralization, and recovery.
Keywords: Emergency preparednessReproductive healthCommunity-based health programmingHealth-system resilienceMaternal healthDisaster risk managementService continuitySub-Saharan Africa
Full text
Text extracted from the article PDF for reading and search. Tables, figures and equations are in the PDF, which remains the authoritative version.
Introduction
Contraceptive use plays a critical role in family planning, improving maternal and child health outcomes, and fostering sustainable development goals (SDGs). Understanding the factors influencing contraceptive use is essential for designing effective public health interventions tailored to the needs of specific populations, Family planning methods, including modern and traditional contraceptives, empower women to manage their reproductive health and achieve their desired family size. Despite the availability of these methods, the prevalence and patterns of contraceptive use vary significantly across regions, often influenced by cultural, social, economic, and health system related [1]. Almost 350,000 women worldwide pass away each year, and an additional 50 million are unwell and disabled because of pregnancy and delivery-related issues [2]. Family planning has a direct impact on women's, children's, and families' health globally, particularly in poor nations. Contraceptives help avoid an estimated 2.7 million newborn deaths and 60 million healthy life losses annually on a global scale [3]. Promoting family planning can save 32% of all maternal fatalities and over 10% of pediatric deaths, as well as alleviate poverty and hunger in nations with high birth rates. Long-term environmental sustainability, universal primary education, and women's empowerment would all benefit greatly from it. The rate of contraceptive use has increased from less than 10% to 60% in recent decades, and family planning initiatives have significantly decreased fertility in poor nations from six to about three births per woman [4].
By lowering unintended pregnancies and decreasing high-risk pregnancies and abortions, family planning has enhanced the wellbeing of families. But family planning initiatives haven't always been as successful in different nations [5]. With the use of several forms of contraception, family planning enables parents to have as many children as they want and to better regulate the spacing of pregnancies. Six Despite numerous discussions concerning the benefits and drawbacks of using contraceptives in various civilizations around the globe, it is widely acknowledged that family planning is essential for preventing unwanted pregnancies, ensuring women's physical and mental well-being, and lowering maternal and infant mortality [6]. Modern contraceptive techniques are also seen to be risky, which has resulted in a number of negative side effects, including discomfort, bleeding, mood swings, and changes in weight [7]. Several studies have highlighted the importance of education in promoting contraceptive use, demonstrating that educated women are more likely to understand and adopt family planning methods [8]. Economic empowerment also plays a critical role, as women with financial independence are often better positioned to negotiate contraceptive use with their. Additionally, the availability of healthcare services and the quality of counseling provided by healthcare providers significantly influence women's contraceptive choices and adherence [9].
Material and Methods
The design: In order to assess factors affecting on contraceptive use in Mosul City, this study used a cross-sectional design from 8 May 2024 to 30 August 2024.
The Sample: A convenience sampling method was used to choose married women (aged 18-41 years) from primary Health center in Mosul city; the number of samples was (204). The research design for this study was a simple randomized.
Study tool: The questionnaire was developed by the researchers and provided for married women to assess factors affecting on contraceptive use in Mosul city. The study instruments comprised (2) Parts, including the following. Part One/Data includes the demographic information (Age, education, occupation,), Part Two/ factors affecting on contraceptive use, Validity (15) Experts on the panel determined the validity of the questionnaire instrument by defining the content's sufficiency, relevance, and clarity.
Reliability To evaluate the reliability of the questionnaire from a statistical standpoint, a pilot study was conducted before starting work to collect data. The experimental sample included (15) samples selected from the health centers (this sample was excluded from the original study sample) through direct self-application of the questionnaire in order to evaluate the internal consistency of the questionnaire that examined the sample. Using Cronbach's alpha measurement, which was evaluated by the researcher, the result of its reliability for an experimental study was that Cronbach's alpha was (0.864).
Data collection
Data were collected by selecting a sample of participants and prompting them to respond with straightforward explanations, avoiding any answers or suggestions that could influence or bias the results. Each takes about 15 to 30 minutes. The researchers conducted face-to-face interviews with the participating married women to deliver the questionnaire.
Table 1: Distribution of sample according to socio- demographic data Demographic Characteristics Frequency Percent Age groups <20 19 9.3 20-29 62 30.4 30-39 101 49.5 <40 22 10.8 Education Illiterate 16 7.8 read &write 16 7.8 primary school 24 11.8 secondary school 39 19.1 collage & above 109 53.4 Occupation Housewife 60 29.4 Workers 101 49.5 Student 43 21.1 Fig 1: Distribution of sample according to contraceptive uses Table 2: Distribution of sample according to type of contraceptive Type of contraceptive uses Frequency Percent birth control pills 45 43.3 Condoms 11 10.6 IUD 36 34.6 Injections 12 11.5 Table 3: Distribution of sample according to reasons for current use of contraceptive Percent Frequency Reasons for current use of contraceptive 30.8 32 To prevent ill 10.6 11 It's Economic 28.8 30 Ensure proper care of children 29.8 31 Prevent pregnancy/birth spacing 100.0 104 Total Table 4: Distribution of sample according to Complications of contraceptive use Percent Frequency Complications of contraceptive uses 12.5 13 Bleeding 23.1 24 Infection 14.4 15 Psychological Pain 14.4 15 Malaise 29.8 31 Amenorrhea 5.8 6 Hypertension 100.0 104 Total Fig 2: Relationship between age groups and contraceptive uses Table 5: Relationship between desired children and contraceptive uses Desired Children Contraceptive use Normal Contraceptive use Total 1-2 62 26 88 3-4 33 52 85 >4 9 22 31 Total 104 100 204
Discussion
Due to its ability to protect women and children from various morbidities and mortality associated with recurrent pregnancies, as well as other socioeconomic benefits, contraceptive techniques have become more popular worldwide. Family planning is recognized as a major factor in mortality and fertility transitions and as an efficient means of enhancing the health of mothers and children in many developing nations [10].
According to multivariate analyses, the most significant explanatory factors of current contraceptive use in Malawi are age, education, number of children born, number of living children, husband's and respondents' approval of family planning, family planning discussions with partners, partner's occupation, and respondent's employment status. Furthermore, the analysis's findings indicate that the usage of contraceptives rises with respondents' ages [11]. The current study was conducted according to Table (1), which shows the distribution of the sample according to demographic and social data. The table shows that out of (204) married women, there were (49.5%) in the age group (30-39) years, while in terms of educational qualification, (53.4%) were university graduates or more, while in terms of profession, (29.4%) were housewives and about (49.5%) were workers. The results of this study are like the study by et al., Alsharif (2023) [12].
Figure (1), which shows the distribution of sample according to contraceptive uses this table shows that (51%) of all studied married women were contraceptive users. The results of this study are like the study by et al., Carlson (2015) [13]. One possible explanation for the low incidence of contraception among women between the ages of 15 and 19 is that many of them are recently married, and marriage is seen as a means of having children. Obtaining family planning services may sometimes be difficult for young moms. According to this research, the respondent's educational attainment is one of the main determinants of the contraceptive issue in Malawi. This suggests that increasing education is a useful tactic for encouraging Malawians to take contraceptives. The results we obtained align with research from other nations and validate the significance of women's economic empowerment.
Table (2), which shows the distribution of sample according to type of contraceptive. This table shows that contraceptive tablets are most used contraception is birth control pills (43.3%) followed by IUD (34.6%) while. the condoms were used by (10.6%) only. The results of this study are like the study More critically, the Malawi National Family Planning Program should adapt its information, education, and communication programs to local conditions in addition to focusing on underserved rural regions. A constant discussion about the different forms of contraception between service providers and customers is necessary to increase the number of clients and alleviate some of their concerns over the alleged negative consequences of contraception. Table (3) distribution of sample according to reasons for current use of Contraceptive. This Table Shows that of the (30.8%) of women use of contraceptive to prevent ill and around (29.8%) to prevent pregnancy.
Table (4) Distribution of sample according to Complications of contraceptive use showed that (29.8%) of the studied sample suffered from amenorrhea Complication followed by (23.1%) of infection Complication. The results of this study are opposite the study by Master-Hunter & Heiman. (2006) [14]. Figure (2) Relationship between age groups and contraceptive uses, this table shows the relationships between the contraceptive use and age.it presents that there was a highly significant between the two factors at(p<0.000). The rate of Contraceptive use was highest among those with (30- 39) years and lowest among those with (20-29) years. These study similar the study by Tiruneh. 2016) [15]. The usage of contraceptives and the intention to use them were likewise linked to age and age at first marriage. It's possible that older women's decreased usage of contraceptives stems from their decreased frequency of sexual activity and the fact that some of them were approaching menopause.
Table (5) Shows the relationships between the contraceptive use and desired children of the studied sample. It presents that the rate of Contraceptive use was highest among those with (1-2) desired children (70.5%)and lowest among those with >4 desired children (29.0%).
References
- Hogan MC, Foreman KJ, Naghavi M, Ahn SY, Wang M, Makela SM, et al. Maternal mortality for 181 countries, 1980–2008: a systematic analysis of progress towards Millennium Development Goal 5. The Lancet.
- Darroch JE, Singh S, Nadeau J. Contraception: an investment in lives, health and development. Issues in Brief (Alan Guttmacher Institute). 2008;(5):1-4.
- Lakew Y, Reda AA, Tamene H, Benedict S, Deribe K. Geographical variation and factors influencing modern contraceptive use among married women in Ethiopia: evidence from a national population-based survey. Reproductive Health. 2013;10:1-10.
- Tiruneh FN, Chuang KY, Ntenda PAM, Chuang YC. Factors associated with contraceptive use and intention to use contraceptives among married women in Ethiopia. Women & Health. 2016;56(1):1-22.
- Gakidou E, Vayena E. Use of modern contraception by the poor is falling behind. PLoS Medicine. 2007;4(2):e31.
- Do M, Kurimoto N. Women's empowerment and choice of contraceptive methods in selected African countries. International Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive Health. 2012;38(1):23-33.
- Abdel-Salam DM, Alrowaily MA, Khalil SN, Al-Muzaini HS, Alhashem AM. Prevalence, correlates, and barriers of contraceptive use among women attending primary health centers in Aljouf Region, Saudi Arabia. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2020;17(10):3552.
- Karamouzian M, Sharifi H, Haghdoost AA. Iran’s shift in family planning policies: concerns and challenges. International Journal of Health Policy and Management. 2014;3(5):231.
- Alsharif SS, Alamri AA, Alamri MA, Altowairqi W, Alsomali AR, Altowairqi AM, et al. Knowledge, attitude, and practice of contraception use among childbearing women in Makkah Region, Saudi Arabia. Cureus. 2023;15(2):e34879.
- Tiruneh FN, Chuang KY, Ntenda PAM, Chuang YC. Factors associated with contraceptive use and intention to use contraceptives among married women in Ethiopia. Women & Health. 2016;56(1):1-22. Copyright and License published articles. This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial-Share A like 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
How to cite
| BibTeX | Download .bib |
|---|---|
| RIS | Download .ris |
| EndNote | Download .enw |
Licensed under CC BY 4.0.